lg_C159_Cover.jpg

md_C159_Cover.jpg

sm_C159_Cover.jpg

thumbnail_C159_Cover.jpg

C159_Cover.jpg

Editorial

This issue takes its inspiration from many different sources: from feminists, gay men, lesbians, queers and transgender people; from those who don’t identify with these categories, such as rural women and men for whom coming out was never an option; and from people in heterosexual relationships who find ways of refusing authoritative and immutable conceptions of gender. Its purpose is not simply to understand how gender is shaped by cultural traditions, social institutions, economics, popular culture and product marketing which is no small task but also to examine how reconceptualizing gender altogether might help us to better understand and relate to one another. In fact, those individuals on the frontlines of this reconceptualization might lead us all in broadening our thinking about experience and self-expression.

To assemble the essays and artist projects that follow, we opened up our editorial-commissioning process to a wider audience, issuing a public call for contributions exploring how maleness is both performed and transformed, and how our contemporary understanding of men is informed by feminism, as well as by ideas of trans and queer identity. As a result, almost all of the feature articles and interviews in this issue reflect a critical and queer approach to masculinity. Furthermore, the majority are grounded in the idea that maleness as a social rather than as a biological category is a cultural construction that is internalized at a psychic level and that intersects with many different facets of who we are, such as our education, social class, nationality and ethnicity. Maleness is a marker of difference that inhabits an especially privileged place in relation to almost all other aspects of identity. And it goes without saying that there’s something wrong with that.

In recent decades, feminist, queer and trans artists have helped us rethink gender difference, distinguishing it from sexual difference and the trappings of biological determinism. In semiotic terms, this rethinking liberated the heavily coded signifiers of gender from the referent of sexual biology. Ensuing conceptions of gender and sexuality have opened up new forms of self expression, helped to recognize alternative family structures, expanded how we experience intimacy and sexual pleasure, enabled the formation of new political solidarities, and given rise to new identities. But even as facets of mainstream society begin embracing these ideas, the result hasn’t been simply more androgynous styles of self-presentation. Instead, we have the campy and hyperperformative embrace of signifiers of masculinity in places like drag king culture — a feature of American and Canadian nightclubs in the 1990s and early 2000s — when women perform various tropes of masculinity in order to reveal its artificiality and theatricality.[^1] And there is Toronto’s ongoing monthly club night Big Primpin, where a queer audience appropriates elements of straight hip-hop identity. However, the self-conscious embrace of highly coded signifiers of gender identity isn’t limited to queer subcultures. The clothing chain Banana Republic recently launched a line inspired by the television drama Mad Men that reflects the highly gendered fashions of the 60s. Or consider The Chap, a parodic British men’s magazine that espouses impeccable manners, tweed clothing and interesting facial hair, publishing articles promoting the lifestyle of the British dandy of the 30s and 40s and also staging Situationist-style public interventions. This broader rethinking of gender helps to explain why mustaches can now be worn only ironically, and also why we can publish an issue entirely dedicated to “men.”

Among the feature articles in this issue, Ken Moffatt looks at the role of shame in the formation of male identity, exploring the work of a number of artists including Kalup Linzy, Johnson Ngo and R.M. Vaughan. He draws our attention to a refusal of acknowledgement and a prohibition that shape both gender and sexuality. Moffatt’s ideas parallel an argument made by Judith Butler in her essay, “Melancholy Gender / Refused Identification, in which she analyzes the psychic formation of gender difference and heterosexual desire through the work of Freud. Stated in the briefest of terms, according to Butler’s theory, children disallowed homosexual attachment from an early age will incorporate the identity of the same-sex parent, but it comes at the expense of the ungrieved loss of same-sex attachment. Stated slightly differently, heterosexual desire is based on the repudiation of same-sex desire and, in turn, the gender of the lost object of desire is preserved as part of one’s own identity.[^2] While the formation of gender is far more complex than can be explored here, these ideas nevertheless still help us to understand the psychic mechanism that lies at the origins of gender identity and heterosexuality, and present a possible understanding of the basis of heterosexism. In Butler and Moffatt’s arguments, prohibition and shame play important roles in shaping male gender identity and male desire.

In the interview “Gender Diasporist,” Shawn Syms talks to Tobaron Waxman about his performance-based works that involve forms of passing in terms of both gender and ethnicity, through masculinizing his appearance and also being read alternately as either Jewish or Muslim. Through his performances, which often incorporate elements of Jewish religious rituals, and through his video and photo-based work, he explores how the state produces particular gendered and racialized identities and helps rethink ideas of Diaspora. Similarly, in this issue’s artist project, which includes a text titled Shit Girls Say, and Lezbros for Lesbos, a centrefold pin-up and poster, reproduced on the inside of the back cover, Logan MacDonald and Jon Davies reflect on what it means as queer men to inhabit some of the same texts, spaces and ideas as their female peers, and also pay homage to these friends and mentors.

Several essays herein critique normative conceptions of male identity. In her essay on the photographs of Chris Ironside, Kerry Manders examines his photographic series Mr. Long Weekend, in which he searches for the “real man” of the Canadian outdoors. As an urban gay man, with no interest in camping, this is an especially elusive ideal for Ironside. Thus, his comic masquerade, in which he performs straight male identity by awkwardly posing in weekend campground scenarios, reveals the instability of notions of masculinity. Nigerian-British artist Yinka Shonibare, another critic of normative masculinity, discusses with Ann Marie Peña the contradictions that underlie popular representations of colonial history through the idea of the flawed hero. Referencing Shonibare’s works that often consist of installations incorporating clothing made of Dutch wax fabric associated with contemporary African identity they consider how these hybrid forms challenge a dominant global order, while invoking masculinity as part of its undoing.

The difficulty with coolly, or even ironically, appropriating elements of any identity, especially a dominant one, is the unquestioned allegiance it often requires. If we can pass as it, we also gain access to the privileges it offers. It is for this reason that our identification must never be complete: it must always hold within it something that it excludes. Our expressions of gender — whatever they may be — thus should aspire to pleasure and also to revealing our individual complexity. And while it might not always be familiar or comfortable, the negotiation of variable, contradictory and expansive identities can enact a more ethical and inclusive society.

[^1]: Judith Halberstam, Female Masculinity (Durham and London: Duke UP, 1998).
[^2]: Judith Butler, “Melancholy Gender / Refused Identification” in Maurice Berger, Brian Wallis, and Simon Watson, eds. Constructing Masculinity (New York and London: Routledge, 1995), 21-36.

Amish Morrell is Assistant Professor at OCAD University, where he teaches Criticism & Curatorial Practice, and Visual and Critical Studies.

Editor

issue-114-p2-3.pdf

Identity

Gender

An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses salient themes within Issue 114, including the male identity, sexuality and the construction of gender. The editor states that identities must never be complete, that they require a reconceptualization, and that we should acknowledge the privileges inherent in dominant gender roles.

Editorial: Men

Feature

Writer

issue-114-p5-9.pdf

Sexuality

The article focuses on the emotion of shame and its role in masculinity . The article discusses shame as a process of social differentiation and exclusion according to such factors as gender and sexuality, its relation to identity formation and the art of R. M. Vaughan, Johnson Ngo and Marina Abramović. The article also discusses the use of the body as a way to question the social and cultural constructs of manliness and shame.

Shame and Men: A Queer Perspective on Masculinity

issue-114-p11-17.pdf

Canadian

Humour

The article discusses the series “Mr. Long Weekend” by artist Chris Ironside. Gender, sexuality and queer identity are addressed in relation to Ironside’s often playful portraits and photographs. Artists: Ironside, Chris

Everything But the Boy: Chris Ironside's Mr. Long Weekend

issue-114-p25-30.pdf

Pop culture

Minimalism

Conceptual

The article focuses on the monochrome series by Canadian artist Ian Wallace. The article discusses Wallace's work within the contexts of 1960s pop, minimalism and conceptualism, compares the monochromes to the work of artists Andy Warhol and Gerhard Richter and discusses Wallace's solo show at Catriona Jeffries in Vancouver, British Columbia in 2007\. The article goes on to compare Wallace's work to the work of artist Barnett Newman. Artists: Gerhard Richter, Barnett Newman, Ian Wallace

Ian Wallace's Monochrome Series

Interview

issue-114-p17-24.pdf

Politics

History

Textiles

An interview with Yinka Shonibare, an artist associated with the Young British Artists, is presented. When asked about his use of Admiral Horatio Nelson in art, Shonibare describes how although Nelson would be a hero of the British Empire or a white male, he would not be considered a hero for rising powers such as Latin America or the East. Shonibare goes on to discuss his participation in “Wide Open School,” a project at the Hayward Gallery by director Ralph Rugoff, and the Dutch fabrics that appear in his artwork. Artists: Rugoff, Ralph, Shonibare, Yinka

A Terrible Beauty: Politics, Sex and the Decline of Empires

Race

Religion

An interview with Canadian artist Tobaron Waxman is presented. When asked about the role of masculinity in his work “Amidah,” Waxman explains that “Amidah” is from a period of his life where he lived in a gender-segregated environment to study Judaism and references a silent prayer recited three times a day for which ten men are present. Waxman goes on to discuss his work “Fear of Bearded Planet” and the stereotype of a Jewish or Arab man.

Gender Diasporist: Shawn Syms interviews Tobaron Waxman

lg_114

md_114

sm_114

thumbnail_114

Chris Lee is a graphic designer and educator based in Buffalo, New York and Toronto. His research explores graphic design’s entanglement with power, standards and legitimacy. Chris is an Assistant Professor at the University at Buffalo SUNY.

Designer

Publisher

Artist Project

Artist

issue-114-p31-32.pdf

Feminism

A fictional letter is presented in which the writer, only identified as Lezbro, discusses the relationship between gay male culture and feminism.

Lezbros for Lesbos

Review

**Gloria Hickey** is an independent curator and writer living in St. John’s, NL. In 2017, Routledge published her book chapter on curatorial strategies in _Exhibiting Craft and Design: Transgressing the White Cube Paradigm_.

issue-114-p44-46.pdf

Nature

The article reviews the exhibition “Michael Flaherty: Rangifer Sapiens” at the Craft Council Gallery in St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador from February 4 – March 11, 2012

Michael Flaherty: Rangifer Sapiens

Jane Affleck is a PhD candidate in the Cultural Studies program at Trent University, a part-time instructor at NSCAD University and a freelance writer.

issue-114-p45-47.pdf

Economy

Social

The article reviews the exhibition “Material World” curated by David Diviney at the Art Gallery of Nova Scotia in Nova Scotia, Halifax from January 21 – May 6, 2012

Material World

issue-114-p46-48.pdf

Environment

Installation

Landscape

The article reviews the exhibition “Seripop: Landscapes Events Reproduced” at the Blackwood Gallery at the University of Toronto in Mississauga, Ontario from January 18 – March 4, 2012

Seripop: Landscapes Events Reproducted

issue-114-p47-49.pdf

Cities

The article reviews the exhibition “My Winnipeg” at the Musée international des arts modestes in Sète, France from November 5, 2011 – April 22, 2012.

My Winnipeg

issue-114-p48-50.pdf

Sculpture

The article reviews the exhibition “A. K. Burns: Pregnant Patron Penny Pot” at Callicoon Fine Arts in New York City from March 3 – April 15, 2012.

A.K. Burns: Pregnant Patron Penny Pot

issue-114-p50-52.pdf

Documentary

The article reviews the exhibition “Christoph Schlingensief: Fear at the Core of Things” at BAK — Basis voor Actuele Kunst in Utrecht, the Netherlands in February 5 – April 29, 2012.

Christoph Schlingensief: Fear at the Core of Things

issue-114-p52-54.pdf

Painting

The article reviews the exhibition “Attila Richard Lukacs from the Collection of Salah J. Bachir” at the Art Gallery of Hamilton from October 8 – December 31, 2011.

Attila Richard Lukacs from the Collection of Salah J. Bachir

**Rose Bouthillier** is Curator (Exhibitions) at Remai Modern in Saskatoon. Previously, she was Associate Curator & Publications Manager at MOCA Cleveland.

Memory

Photography

The article reviews an exhibition by artist Althea Thauberger at the Susan Hobbs Gallery in Toronto, Ontario from January 26 – March 3, 2012

Althea Thauberger

issue-114-p54-55.pdf

The article reviews the exhibition “Andrea Zittel: Lay of My Land” at Regen Projects in Los Angeles, California from September 16 – October 29, 2011

Andrea Zittel: Lay of My Land

issue-114-p57-59.pdf

The article reviews the exhibition “Declining Democracy” at the Centro di Cultura Contemporanea Strozzina in Florence, Italy from September 23, 2011 – January 22, 2012.

Declining Democracy

issue-114-p58-60.pdf

The article reviews the exhibition “A Refusal of Images” curated by Vicky Moufawad-Paul at A Space Gallery in Toronto, Ontario from January 20 – March 2, 2012.

A Refusal of Images

issue-114-p60-61.pdf

Participation

Relational art

The article reviews the book “Radical Prototypes: Allan Kaprow and the Invention of Happenings” by Judith F. Rodenbeck.

Radical Prototypes: Allan Kaprow and the Invention of Happenings, by Judith F. Rodenbeck

issue-114-p61-62.pdf

Art movements

The article reviews the book “Contemporary Art in North America” edited by Michael Wilson.

Contemporary Art in North America, edited by Michael Wilson

issue-114-p62-63.pdf

Performance

Curatorial practice

The article reviews the book “Martha Wilson Sourcebook: 40 Years of Reconsidering, Performance, Feminism, Alternative Spaces” by Independent Curators International.

Martha Wilson Sourcebook: 40 Years of Reconsidering Performance, Feminism, Alternative Spaces, by Independent Curators International

issue-114-p63-64.pdf

Multiples

The article provides reviews for websites, books and exhibitions including the website Art.sy, the monograph “Oliver Husain, Spoiler Alert” edited by Michael Maranda and the periodical “Journal for Artistic Research.”

Header

C Mag

Issue 114

Men

Credits